Detectives investigate the murder of Rhonda Smith at Trinity Lutheran and confront a confused and frightened congregation in a place of turmoil.
Mary Jane Fonder was a longtime member of the church and a close friend of the pastor, but her behavior started to change when a new pastor arrived. She began attending more services, and something seemed off.
In this podcast, a pastor recounts the story of Mary Jane, a woman who had feelings for him and whose mysterious disappearance continues to haunt him and the community.