Chapter

Jeff's odd behavior after a night of shooting at the Pelleys' house
listen on Spotify
19:35 - 23:29 (03:53)

Jeff leaves the Pelleys' house after the shooting and heads to prom like nothing happened, despite collecting all of the bullet casings and locking all doors and windows. He does not seem to have a close relationship with the group who was at the house with him.

Clips
Jeff Pelline was last seen on the day of his senior prom in 1975.
19:35 - 20:41 (01:06)
listen on Spotify
Unsolved Mystery
Summary

Jeff Pelline was last seen on the day of his senior prom in 1975. His whereabouts remain unknown to this day.

Chapter
Jeff's odd behavior after a night of shooting at the Pelleys' house
Episode
INFAMOUS: Prom Night Murders
Podcast
Crime Junkie
Jeff's alibi is being questioned as he was seen at a gas station fixing his car 20 minutes after the estimated time of the murder, which conflicts with his initial statement of leaving his house at 4:55 pm.
20:41 - 21:29 (00:47)
listen on Spotify
Murder case
Summary

Jeff's alibi is being questioned as he was seen at a gas station fixing his car 20 minutes after the estimated time of the murder, which conflicts with his initial statement of leaving his house at 4:55 pm.

Chapter
Jeff's odd behavior after a night of shooting at the Pelleys' house
Episode
INFAMOUS: Prom Night Murders
Podcast
Crime Junkie
Jeff goes to prom after allegedly killing his father and staging the scene to appear as a suicide.
21:29 - 23:29 (02:00)
listen on Spotify
Crime
Summary

Jeff goes to prom after allegedly killing his father and staging the scene to appear as a suicide.

Chapter
Jeff's odd behavior after a night of shooting at the Pelleys' house
Episode
INFAMOUS: Prom Night Murders
Podcast
Crime Junkie