Chapter

Second Trial Verdict for a Murder Case on Nantucket
listen on Spotify
33:23 - 40:11 (06:48)

With a new defense attorney, the second trial for the murder case of Tom Tulin was considerably shorter, and the verdict of guilty for first degree murder and assault and battery with a dangerous weapon was reached the same day.

Clips
The trial of Thomas Tulin III for the murder of Beth Lochteveld begins.
33:23 - 36:02 (02:39)
listen on Spotify
True Crime
Summary

The trial of Thomas Tulin III for the murder of Beth Lochteveld begins. The prosecutor argues that Tulin was criminally responsible for the stabbing and presented evidence to show that he boarded a plane without a knife the next day.

Chapter
Second Trial Verdict for a Murder Case on Nantucket
Episode
Fatal Attraction
Podcast
Dateline NBC
The jury in the Tom Tulin trial reaches a verdict after five hours of deliberation.
36:02 - 36:47 (00:45)
listen on Spotify
Trial
Summary

The jury in the Tom Tulin trial reaches a verdict after five hours of deliberation. The tension in the courtroom is palpable as the defendant awaits the verdict.

Chapter
Second Trial Verdict for a Murder Case on Nantucket
Episode
Fatal Attraction
Podcast
Dateline NBC
A defendant with a history of drug and alcohol abuse, as well as underlying mental health problems, is found guilty of first-degree murder and assault with a deadly weapon, despite a new defense attorney's efforts to present the insanity defense.
36:47 - 39:12 (02:25)
listen on Spotify
Insanity Defense
Summary

A defendant with a history of drug and alcohol abuse, as well as underlying mental health problems, is found guilty of first-degree murder and assault with a deadly weapon, despite a new defense attorney's efforts to present the insanity defense.

Chapter
Second Trial Verdict for a Murder Case on Nantucket
Episode
Fatal Attraction
Podcast
Dateline NBC
Thomas Tulin has been found guilty of murder, of stabbing Elizabeth Lachtelfeld 23 times until she died 52 days after meeting her, and has been sentenced to life in prison.
39:12 - 40:11 (00:59)
listen on Spotify
Crime
Summary

Thomas Tulin has been found guilty of murder, of stabbing Elizabeth Lachtelfeld 23 times until she died 52 days after meeting her, and has been sentenced to life in prison. Tulin is appealing his conviction.

Chapter
Second Trial Verdict for a Murder Case on Nantucket
Episode
Fatal Attraction
Podcast
Dateline NBC