Chapter

The Disappearance of Elizabeth Olten
listen on Spotify
02:11 - 12:15 (10:04)

Volunteers and law enforcement worked tirelessly to find 9-year-old Elizabeth Olten who was missing from her home; and during this investigation, her 15-year-old stepsister Alyssa, who had claimed she saw Elizabeth walking towards the woods, became a person of interest.

Clips
Volunteers, search dogs, and dive teams scoured ponds and rivers for Elizabeth Olten, who had gone missing on October 21, 2009.
02:11 - 06:45 (04:34)
listen on Spotify
Elizabeth Olten
Summary

Volunteers, search dogs, and dive teams scoured ponds and rivers for Elizabeth Olten, who had gone missing on October 21, 2009. Search teams gathered at the Extreme Body and Paint Shop at 7:30 pm in hopes of finding her alive.

Chapter
The Disappearance of Elizabeth Olten
Episode
Second Grave
Podcast
Sword and Scale Nightmares
During an interrogation, Detective Rice questions Alyssa Bustamante about digging a hole in the woods and what she was doing in the hours leading up to when her stepsister heard cries in the thorn bushes outside her bedroom window.
06:45 - 12:15 (05:29)
listen on Spotify
Crime
Summary

During an interrogation, Detective Rice questions Alyssa Bustamante about digging a hole in the woods and what she was doing in the hours leading up to when her stepsister heard cries in the thorn bushes outside her bedroom window. Alyssa's grandmother is also present and provides additional details.

Chapter
The Disappearance of Elizabeth Olten
Episode
Second Grave
Podcast
Sword and Scale Nightmares