The defense in the Duke Lacrosse case claimed that Raven, one of the accused players, couldn't have committed the crime because he arrived at a game only minutes before it started; journalist Karen Ganss investigates the case and expresses doubt about the police's approach.
Detectives investigating a cold case involving the murder of Dana Welch find new evidence linking Richard Tully, Welch's neighbor, to the crime scene; however, investigators also become suspicious of a man who had never been considered a person of interest in the case.
Authorities investigate clues found in Kelly's bedroom and bathroom after discovering her dead body there. They collect evidence like clothes, fingerprints, and residues from cleaning supplies in the hope of finding her killer.
The podcast hosts discuss the questionable evidence in a criminal investigation and speculate whether it is just a tactic or if the investigators actually have something substantial. The sheriff in charge of the case is described as "old school".
Touch DNA is a new technology that allows forensic experts to extract DNA from skin cells the suspect leaves behind on an object. It has helped solve a lot of crimes by identifying suspects through their distant family members who have committed crimes in the past when direct matches are not available.