Two detectives investigate the cold case of the murder of Jennifer Bastian and Michella Welch back in 1986, relentlessly trying to solve the case even decades later.
Michelle Martinko was brutally murdered and found partially slumped on the passenger seat of a car. The killer left behind glove prints and blood trails which led to the investigation of the crime.
New details have emerged from the investigation into Carla Walker's murder, including the trip from the bowling alley to the location where her body was found and letters sent to the police. Rodney, the prime suspect, initially claimed he woke up five minutes after being knocked unconscious.
Michelle's friend tells the police about a young man named Oliver O'Quinn, who was a nurse at a nearby hospital, and who she knew through her best friend. As evidence mounts, the question arises whether he could have been involved in Michelle's murder.
The detectives in Michelle Martinko's case investigate a lead by a white man named Richard who becomes defensive and suspicious when asked about Michelle.