This episode follows the murders of Christine and Wendy, two women murdered on Christmas Eve with a year apart in Pearland, Houston, Texas. Police find similarities in the murders and start a complex investigation that eventually leads to an unlikely suspect.
A young girl's disappearance in a small town strips away the innocence of the community, who initially believed that they would quickly have a solved case in the young man who was with her last.
Rachel Cooke disappeared in 2002 while taking a morning jog in Georgetown, Texas. Despite sightings of her and a few potential suspects, her case remains unsolved.
While investigating Melissa Lewis's murder, police asked Melissa's best friend, Deborah Villegas, if she knew anyone who lived in Miami Gardens. Deborah said her husband Tony lived there, and police now had a new suspect - someone close to Deborah, but who barely knew Melissa.
In this episode, the hosts investigate the case of Jennifer Pan, a woman who attempted to murder her tiger parents in order to escape the immense pressure they had put on her all her life. Through police investigations, her upbringing is analyzed and we learn about her experiences with tiger parenting.