This episode follows the murders of Christine and Wendy, two women murdered on Christmas Eve with a year apart in Pearland, Houston, Texas. Police find similarities in the murders and start a complex investigation that eventually leads to an unlikely suspect.
Darlene Hulse was abducted and murdered 38 years ago, leaving behind young children who never got answers about what happened to their mother. The case has been reopened and investigators think they may finally be close to solving it.
A woman with dark hair picked up a two-year-old girl playing outside a motel in South Lake Tahoe, claiming she was trying to help find the girl's mother.
Cynthia watches her brother Sean settle in to watch a scary movie while she heads to bed. The next day, her fear grows as they roam the streets searching for him after he goes missing.
After Nikki LaDue January's body was found, the police discovered a piece of peculiar plywood covering her body with a silver spray-painted figure on it. Nikki's family is left with many questions about the death of their loved one.