The police found a blood trail on the sidewalk that led to the stabbing of an unknown woman. A bloody matchbox was discovered 350 feet from the crime scene, possibly with a visible hand or fingerprint mark.
Inconsistent statements made by Karen lead to a search warrant for her home where the police found alcohol bottles, a blender, and transfer blood on a bar stool, likely from the altercation mentioned in Karen's story.
The death of Anna Marie was first thought to be an accident, but when the police found her wife Cara covered in paint and rigor mortis already set in, it pointed towards foul play in this mysterious and tragic case.
The suspect in the crime left behind hair and blood droppings in his vehicle when he transported the body after choking the victim to death, which is a common occurrence due to the bursting out of blood vessels in the throat.
Mark Winger calls 911 to report his wife, Donna, has been shot in their home but further evidence reveals that he may have been the one to murder her.