In a discussion about the murder of JonBenet Ramsey, the host and guest float the possibility of her brother being the killer due to the lack of forced entry and some behavioral cues, although the host later hopes that this isn't the case.
Rita accuses Tyler of stealing valuable items, including gold, from a property where a man was later found dead of cyanide poisoning. However, police have not found evidence connecting Tyler to the death.
After the failure to solve a murder case for sixteen years, a detective receives a surprising call. DNA from the Screwdriver Red Killer was found on a prostitute that was killed in 1993.
A witness recalls learning new and surprising information during a trial they attended, specifically about the accused contacting someone after their arrest.
Rose Larner's disappearance led to a gruesome discovery of drugs, sex, murder, and body parts inside the home of her ex-boyfriend John's grandparents' house. Her killers fled to Mexico, but were eventually caught and charged with murder, with DNA evidence proving that John was responsible for her death.
Ashley's uncle John testified about Tom's sudden outburst when he found out Ashley asked him for a joint. A neighbor also reported Ashley told her about Tom being physically aggressive towards her. The prosecution is trying to prove that Tom's anger and hot temper could have been the motive for murder.