In Part 2 of the episode, the hosts explore what a neighbor saw on the day Jenny Lin was murdered and the investigative avenues police took to solve the case; the episode ends with a plea for information.
In part two of Michelle Eason's story, police are determined to crack their main suspect in the serial missing persons cases that might be related to Michelle's. With the help of an FBI profiler, they devise a plan to finally corner him, leading to the discovery of the horrifying truths behind the missing persons cases.
Sylvia Likens was brutally tortured and murdered by Gertrude Baniszewski and her children, with the help of neighborhood kids. When police arrived, they were disturbed by the horrfic condition of Sylvia's body and through questioning Jenny, they were able to arrest the perpetrators.
Lynn Robitaille's son Kyle died from a drug overdose in Pine Manor, but she believes his death was not properly investigated. She launched a media campaign to bring attention to the case and get answers.
Brenda Spencer is a prime suspect in the murder case of Jennifer Servo, who was reported missing for 20 years, but whose remains has yet to be found. The Sheriff's office believes there's enough circumstantial evidence to prosecute Spencer and find justice for the case.