Episode

And Then There Were Three
listen on Spotify
40:40
Published: Thu Sep 17 2020
Description

Just days before Christmas, high school senior Michelle Martinko is found stabbed to death in her car after visiting the mall. It would take almost 40 years for investigators to identify the killer – and when they did, Martinko’s family and friends were stunned. Dennis Murphy reports.

Chapters
A young girl's brutal murder in the 1970s sparked an investigation in a small Iowa town.
00:00 - 01:35 (01:35)
listen on Spotify
Crime
Summary

A young girl's brutal murder in the 1970s sparked an investigation in a small Iowa town. Despite theories involving drug and prostitution rings, it took decades for the case to be cracked, with a breakthrough coming from an unexpected source.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
Michelle Martinko, a high school senior, was found dead in her car outside of a mall in Iowa in 1979.
01:35 - 05:54 (04:18)
listen on Spotify
True Crime
Summary

Michelle Martinko, a high school senior, was found dead in her car outside of a mall in Iowa in 1979. Her murder remained unsolved for decades until DNA evidence led to the arrest and conviction of her killer in 2019.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
The murder case of Michelle Martinko remains unsolved.
05:54 - 09:14 (03:20)
listen on Spotify
True crime
Summary

The murder case of Michelle Martinko remains unsolved. Blood typing was used to try to find the killer who may have left traces of his blood, however no further leads have surfaced.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
A student expresses to her teacher that she is tired of belonging to somebody and how that relates to her past experiences in junior high school.
09:14 - 13:11 (03:57)
listen on Spotify
Education
Summary

A student expresses to her teacher that she is tired of belonging to somebody and how that relates to her past experiences in junior high school.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
Detectives question the alibi of the suspect in the Michelle Martinko murder case after discrepancies arise in his story.
13:11 - 18:04 (04:53)
listen on Spotify
Michelle Martinko
Summary

Detectives question the alibi of the suspect in the Michelle Martinko murder case after discrepancies arise in his story.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
Detective Doug Larison shares the process of using DNA evidence to solve a 1979 cold case, from obtaining suspects' DNA samples to eliminating them from the partial profile, to finally identifying the true killer.
18:07 - 23:14 (05:07)
listen on Spotify
DNA Evidence
Summary

Detective Doug Larison shares the process of using DNA evidence to solve a 1979 cold case, from obtaining suspects' DNA samples to eliminating them from the partial profile, to finally identifying the true killer.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
Parabon NanoLabs uses genetic genealogy to help solve cold cases by identifying possible family members of the perpetrator and building a family tree to link them to the crime scene.
23:14 - 26:43 (03:29)
listen on Spotify
Genetic Genealogy
Summary

Parabon NanoLabs uses genetic genealogy to help solve cold cases by identifying possible family members of the perpetrator and building a family tree to link them to the crime scene.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
The suspect list for the murder of Michelle Martinko had narrowed down to three brothers living in Iowa, and the police tracked each one down, starting with the middle brother Kenneth, until they finally found the culprit, the youngest brother Jerry Burns, who had left his DNA at the crime scene.
26:43 - 32:46 (06:03)
listen on Spotify
True crime
Summary

The suspect list for the murder of Michelle Martinko had narrowed down to three brothers living in Iowa, and the police tracked each one down, starting with the middle brother Kenneth, until they finally found the culprit, the youngest brother Jerry Burns, who had left his DNA at the crime scene.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
Defense attorney Leon Spies filed a motion to bar the computer evidence from the trial, questioning police handling of the evidence from four decades ago.
32:46 - 39:00 (06:14)
listen on Spotify
Legal Proceedings
Summary

Defense attorney Leon Spies filed a motion to bar the computer evidence from the trial, questioning police handling of the evidence from four decades ago. Despite this, the defendant was found guilty of murder in the first degree.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC
After three hours of deliberation, Jerry Burns was sentenced to life in prison without parole for the 1979 murder of Michelle Martinko, bringing long-awaited closure to her family.
39:00 - 40:28 (01:28)
listen on Spotify
Justice
Summary

After three hours of deliberation, Jerry Burns was sentenced to life in prison without parole for the 1979 murder of Michelle Martinko, bringing long-awaited closure to her family.

Episode
And Then There Were Three
Podcast
Dateline NBC