Episode
The Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
1:10:38
Published: Mon Mar 13 2023
Description
Cary Hartmann brings look-alikes to a police lineup in the Ogden City Rapist case. His TV reporter friend Larry Lewis tests the boundaries of journalistic ethics when Cary goes to trial. Police detective Jack Bell receives a letter about Sheree Warren and the TV show “Unsolved Mysteries.”Season 3 of Cold includes descriptions of rape, sexual assault, murder and domestic violence. Please take care when listening.Follow Cold Season 3: The Search for Sheree wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all 10 episodes ad-free only on Amazon Music. Or you can listen early and ad-free on Wondery+ in Apple Podcasts or the Wondery App.Please support us by supporting our sponsors!BetterHelp - This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/COLD and get on your way to being your best self.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Chapters
Weber County Attorney Reed Richards believed he had the Ogden City rapist in his sights and charged Carrie Hartman with a string of home invasion sexual assaults, although evidence was short and only one woman could identify her attacker from a photo lineup.
00:00 - 01:15 (01:15)
Summary
Weber County Attorney Reed Richards believed he had the Ogden City rapist in his sights and charged Carrie Hartman with a string of home invasion sexual assaults, although evidence was short and only one woman could identify her attacker from a photo lineup.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
After Caroline identified the wrong man amongst three similar-looking individuals in a police lineup that was potentially influenced by the defendant's attorney, a defense attorney was present during her second lineup identification a year later.
01:15 - 06:07 (04:51)
Summary
After Caroline identified the wrong man amongst three similar-looking individuals in a police lineup that was potentially influenced by the defendant's attorney, a defense attorney was present during her second lineup identification a year later.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
A woman, known as Caroline, identified her alleged sexual assault attacker, Kerry Hartman, in a lineup the day before testifying at Hartman's preliminary hearing.
06:07 - 09:28 (03:21)
Summary
A woman, known as Caroline, identified her alleged sexual assault attacker, Kerry Hartman, in a lineup the day before testifying at Hartman's preliminary hearing.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
Kerry was busy planning to avoid the police when they were searching for Sheree, including arranging for an imposter at the lineup, while Shauna turned over evidence to the police that could implicate her estranged husband.
09:28 - 14:50 (05:21)
Summary
Kerry was busy planning to avoid the police when they were searching for Sheree, including arranging for an imposter at the lineup, while Shauna turned over evidence to the police that could implicate her estranged husband.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
The forensic exam in rape cases involves looking for blood, saliva, or semen on the victim, clothing, or bedding for comparison with samples taken from a suspect.
14:50 - 21:50 (06:59)
Summary
The forensic exam in rape cases involves looking for blood, saliva, or semen on the victim, clothing, or bedding for comparison with samples taken from a suspect. The rape kit comprises clothing, bedding, swabs, and bodily fluids which are gathered as evidence for further examination.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
The defense in a rape trial is challenging key evidence presented by prosecutors, including statements made by the defendant to police, information from police lab tests, and a victim's testimony.
21:50 - 26:22 (04:32)
Summary
The defense in a rape trial is challenging key evidence presented by prosecutors, including statements made by the defendant to police, information from police lab tests, and a victim's testimony.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
Journalist reveals her reaction to a colleague's failure to disclose a personal relationship with a source, while also discussing the use of pre-sentence reports in the judicial system.
26:22 - 34:25 (08:03)
Summary
Journalist reveals her reaction to a colleague's failure to disclose a personal relationship with a source, while also discussing the use of pre-sentence reports in the judicial system.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
Reed Slatkin avoids additional charges in his fraud case, but could still face up to 15 years in prison.
34:25 - 39:44 (05:18)
Summary
Reed Slatkin avoids additional charges in his fraud case, but could still face up to 15 years in prison. Carrie is worried about his relationship with Shauna but denies any violence.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
The focus of the investigation shifts to Cherie's co-worker, who took the day off on the day of Cherie's disappearance and may have had the opportunity to take her car to Vegas.
39:44 - 44:57 (05:12)
Summary
The focus of the investigation shifts to Cherie's co-worker, who took the day off on the day of Cherie's disappearance and may have had the opportunity to take her car to Vegas. Meanwhile, the main suspect has invoked his right to silence, hindering the investigation.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
Despite a conviction of five years to life, this former police officer avoids further prison time by serving his sentence concurrently with another.
44:57 - 49:04 (04:07)
Summary
Despite a conviction of five years to life, this former police officer avoids further prison time by serving his sentence concurrently with another. Kerry, the former officer, expresses his fear of being kept at the main prison due to his history.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
Scott Carrier reflects on unsolved mysteries and the intersection between Christianity and these unknowns, pondering the mysteries of the disappearance of Cherie Warren and the crimes of a serial rapist in Salt Lake City.
49:04 - 53:07 (04:02)
Summary
Scott Carrier reflects on unsolved mysteries and the intersection between Christianity and these unknowns, pondering the mysteries of the disappearance of Cherie Warren and the crimes of a serial rapist in Salt Lake City.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
Blaine Carriot was charged with four cases of rape by the Weber County Attorney, despite detectives believing he had committed many more.
53:07 - 58:31 (05:24)
Summary
Blaine Carriot was charged with four cases of rape by the Weber County Attorney, despite detectives believing he had committed many more. Carriot had assaulted three women in a single week in March of 1988.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
The details of who committed which murders in a case involving B-type blood found in forensic evidence are unknown, with uncertainty surrounding which murders were committed by whom.
58:31 - 1:04:24 (05:52)
Summary
The details of who committed which murders in a case involving B-type blood found in forensic evidence are unknown, with uncertainty surrounding which murders were committed by whom.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
The social worker noted that 'Carrie' made efforts to manage his anger, but recounted a detailed account of his girlfriend's disappearance while claiming innocence of sexual assault.
1:04:24 - 1:08:13 (03:49)
Summary
The social worker noted that 'Carrie' made efforts to manage his anger, but recounted a detailed account of his girlfriend's disappearance while claiming innocence of sexual assault.
EpisodeThe Search for Sheree | Nighthawk | 5
PodcastCold
The trial of the Chicago 7 highlighted cultural divisions in the US during a symbolic fight about the country's soul and future.
1:08:13 - 1:12:00 (03:47)
Summary
The trial of the Chicago 7 highlighted cultural divisions in the US during a symbolic fight about the country's soul and future.